Buying vs. Renting

During a PCS

How to Make the Right Call When You Don’t Know How Long You’ll Be Here

Play PrevUnderstanding the VA Loan

Play NextCredit and VA Loan Readiness

RETURN TO MILITARY EDUCATION

Reserve Your Consultation

Buying vs. Renting During a PCS

You’ve got orders, a report date, and a hundred things to figure out — and somewhere in the middle of all of it sits one big question: do we buy, or do we rent? It’s one of the first real decisions every military family faces at a new duty station, and there’s a lot of bad advice floating around about it. Some folks will tell you renting is always a waste. Others will tell you to buy the second you hit town. The truth, like most things, sits in the middle — and it depends on you.

Let’s take the pressure off and walk through it honestly, so you can make the call that’s right for your family and your orders — not somebody’s one-size-fits-all rule.

✦ Captain’s Log

When my family and I first arrived in Hampton Roads, we didn’t rush out and buy. We rented first. I didn’t know the area yet, and I wanted to get a real feel for the neighborhoods, the commutes, and where we actually wanted to plant. A few years later, once we knew this was home, we bought — and I’ve never regretted taking that first step slow.

So hear me when I say this: renting first isn’t a failure, and it isn’t throwing money away. Sometimes it’s the smartest opening move you can make. The key is knowing which situation you’re actually in.

The Case for Renting

Renting gets a bad rap, but there are real situations where it’s the smart play:

Short or uncertain tour. If you might be here a year or two, the costs of buying and selling can eat any gain before you ever see it.
You don’t know the area yet. Renting buys you time to learn the neighborhoods and commutes before you commit. We’ll dig into choosing the right area in Blog 5.
You’re not financially ready. If your credit or savings need a little work first, renting for a season while you get set up can be the right move. That’s exactly what Blog 3 is about.
You want zero maintenance headaches. When the water heater goes, it’s the landlord’s problem, not yours. For some seasons of life, that peace of mind is worth it.

The Case for Buying

Now the other side — and for a lot of service members, this is where the real opportunity lives:

You build equity instead of your landlord’s. Every mortgage payment builds something you own. Rent builds something someone else owns.
Your VA loan makes getting in easy. Zero down, no PMI — the barriers that stop civilian buyers barely apply to you. We covered that in Blog 1.
Your BAH can cover the mortgage. In many cases your housing allowance covers most or all of your payment, so you’re building wealth with money you were spending anyway. Blog 4 does that math with you.
You can keep it when you leave. This is the big one for military families — buy now, and when you PCS you may be able to rent it out instead of selling. More on that in a minute.

The Real Question: How Long Will You Be Here?

Strip everything else away and it usually comes down to time. Buying and selling a home isn’t free — there are closing costs on the way in and on the way out. You generally need to stay put long enough for your equity and any appreciation to outrun those costs. As a rough rule, the longer you’ll be at a duty station, the more buying tips in your favor.

So be honest with yourself about your timeline. How long is this tour? Is it likely to extend? Could you see yourself staying in the area even after the uniform comes off? Hampton Roads is a place a lot of us never leave — and that changes the math. We’ll line your purchase up against your actual orders and report date in Blog 8.

⚠ Captain’s Warning

Here’s where I’ve watched good people get hurt. Buying a home and then getting surprise orders a few months later — in a market that’s dipped — can force you to sell at a loss, or scramble to rent it out before you’ve even finished unpacking.

If there’s a real chance you’ll be moved fast, or if the numbers only work when absolutely nothing goes wrong, slow down. A home you’re forced to sell in a hurry can cost you far more than a year of rent ever would. Buy from a position of strength, not a gamble.

⚓ Captain’s Course Correction

You’ve heard it your whole life: “renting is throwing money away.” It’s not that simple. Rent buys you flexibility — and flexibility has real value when your next set of orders is still a question mark.

But the flip side is just as true. “Always buy, no matter what” is bad advice too. Neither renting nor buying is automatically right. The smart move is the one that fits your timeline, your numbers, and how settled you and your family actually are.

The Military Wealth Move: Buy, Then Keep It as a Rental

Strip everything else away and it usually comes down to time. Buying and selling a home isn’t free — there are closing costs on the way in and on the way out. You generally need to stay put long enough for your equity and any appreciation to outrun those costs. As a rough rule, the longer you’ll be at a duty station, the more buying tips in your favor.

So be honest with yourself about your timeline. How long is this tour? Is it likely to extend? Could you see yourself staying in the area even after the uniform comes off? Hampton Roads is a place a lot of us never leave — and that changes the math. We’ll line your purchase up against your actual orders and report date in Blog 8.

The Hampton Roads Angle

This market makes the buy-side case stronger than most places in the country. The military presence isn’t going anywhere, values here tend to grind steadily upward without the wild swings you see elsewhere, and the renter pool runs deep and constant. That combination is what makes the “buy and hold it” play so workable here — if your timeline supports it.

A Simple Way to Decide

1. How long is your tour — and could it extend? The longer you’ll be here, the more buying makes sense.

2. Do you know the area yet? If not, renting first — like I did — buys you time to choose well. (Blog 5)

3. Are your credit and finances ready? Getting set up first means better loan terms. (Blog 3)

4. Does the math work on your BAH? Run the real numbers before you fall for a house. (Blog 4)

5. Could you rent it out if orders came? If yes, buying gets a lot safer — and a lot smarter. (Blog 9)

6. Do you have a cushion for the unexpected? A little breathing room protects every other decision you make.

One Last Thing

There’s no trophy for buying the fastest, and there’s no shame in renting for a season while you get your feet under you. I’ve done both, and I’ve helped plenty of families do both. What matters is that you make the call with clear eyes and real numbers — not pressure, and not somebody’s blanket rule.

If you’re staring down a PCS and trying to figure out whether to buy or rent here in Hampton Roads, let’s talk it through. I’ll help you look at your actual timeline and numbers, veteran to veteran, with no pressure either way.

Let's Talk

Trying to decide whether to buy or rent during your PCS? Book a free consultation at coastalva.chat — we’ll look at your real timeline and numbers together, with no obligation.

Book Your Free Consultation → coastalva.chat

Play PrevUnderstanding the VA Loan

Play NextCredit and VA Loan Readiness

RETURN TO MILITARY EDUCATION

Reserve Your Consultation

About the Author: Marc Ian Griffin, aka Captain Real Estate, is a licensed REALTOR and Wealth Advisor with Coastal VA Estates LLC, powered by Keller Williams Town Center. A retired U.S. Navy veteran, Marc has called the Hampton Roads area home since 1992. He entered real estate in 2006 because he saw what was happening to everyday families who were losing thousands and, in many cases, losing their homes simply because they didn't have the right person guiding them through the potential real estate pitfalls — and he was determined to be that person. After a period away from the industry, he returned in 2025 with that same mission. Marc serves buyers and sellers across Virginia Beach, Norfolk, Chesapeake, Portsmouth, Suffolk, Hampton, and Newport News.